The USS North Carolina (BB-55) My all-time favorite warship. As an elementary school student in North Carolina, I donated nickels and dimes to save this ship back in the early sixties.

Saturday, May 14, 2022

Japanese Atom Bomb Survivors-- Part 5: Was It Necessary to Use the Bomb?

The bombings set off a nuclear arms race in the Cold War.  The United States justified the bombings as a way to save lives by preventing an invasion of mainland Japan to end the war, a view long accepted by many Americans.

But, Gar Alperovitz, author of "Atomic Diplomacy:  Hiroshima and Potsdam and the Decision to Use the Atom Bomb," said at a recent online event that documentary records show wartime American leaders knew of Japan's imminent surrender and the bombings were not necessary militarily.

Myself, I am not so sure we knew for a fact that Japan was going to soon surrender.  Considering their mindset against surrender (and how they treated enemies who surrendered), I can't think that even with the odds so much against them that they would have surrendered without an extremely huge death and casualty toll n both sides.

However, I would have liked to see a little more time given Japan to surrender without using the atom bombs.  Or, perhaps picking a non -populated island to show the power of the bomb.

--GreGen


No comments:

Post a Comment